List of Subway Store Stores in Otterbein, IN Outlet Note Regular Brands Subway Store Indiana Otterbein Rating 4.6 based on 64 votes Official Website http://www.subway.com/ Products Bread Breakfast Salads Pizza Sandwiches Veggie Patty Pastrami Flatbread Veggie Delight Footlong NameAddressPhone Name/Address/Phone Subway Store outlet - Otterbein 500 W Otterbein St (765) 583-4080 People Also Viewed