List of Progressive Stores in Valley Stream, NY Outlet Note Regular Brands Progressive New York Valley Stream Rating 4.9 based on 69 votes Official Website https://www.progressive.com/ Products Car Insurance NameAddressPhone Name/Address/Phone Progressive outlet - Valley Stream 99 W Hawthorne Ave (516) 218-2050 Progressive outlet - Valley Stream 475 W Merrick Rd (516) 593-5484 Progressive outlet - Valley Stream 515 Rockaway Ave (516) 837-6200 People Also Viewed