List of Progressive Stores in Toms River, NJ Outlet Note Regular Brands Progressive New Jersey Toms River Rating 4.9 based on 69 votes Official Website https://www.progressive.com/ Products Car Insurance NameAddressPhone Name/Address/Phone Progressive outlet - Toms River 44 Flint Rd (732) 244-0109 Progressive outlet - Toms River 520 Main St (732) 557-4422 Progressive outlet - Toms River 1 Easton Rd (732) 281-3201 People Also Viewed