List of Payless ShoeSource Stores in Bay Shore, NY Outlet Note Regular Brands Payless ShoeSource New York Bay Shore Rating 4.5 based on 87 votes Official Outlet www.payless.com/search?pmid=saleandclearance Official Website http://www.payless.com/ Products Boots Shoes Flats Sneakers Slippers Sandals Accessories Athletics NameAddressPhone Name/Address/Phone Payless ShoeSource outlet - Bay Shore Westfield South Shore (631) 968-6339 Payless ShoeSource outlet - Bay Shore Gardner Manor Mall 846 Sunrise Hwy (631) 968-1750 People Also Viewed