List of Papa John's Pizza Stores in Newark, NJ Outlet Note Regular Brands Papa John's Pizza New Jersey Newark Rating 4.9 based on 58 votes Products Pizza Heart Shaped Pizza Large Pizza NameAddressPhone Name/Address/Phone Papa John's Pizza outlet - Newark 1013 Broad St (973) 596-6000 Papa John's Pizza outlet - Newark 451 Bloomfield Ave (973) 482-7272 Papa John's Pizza outlet - Newark 381 South Orange Ave (973) 353-9200 People Also Viewed