List of First Niagara Bank Stores in New City, NY Outlet Note Regular Brands First Niagara Bank New York New City Rating 4.9 based on 62 votes Official Website https://www.firstniagara.com/home.aspx Products Banking NameAddressPhone Name/Address/Phone First Niagara Bank outlet - New City 219 S Main St (845) 634-4664 First Niagara Bank outlet - New City 14 Central Ave (845) 352-6900 First Niagara Bank outlet - New City 219 S Main St People Also Viewed