List of CITGO Stores in Newcomerstown, OH Outlet Note Regular Brands CITGO Ohio Newcomerstown Rating 4.5 based on 53 votes Products Convenience Stores Gas Stations Natural Gas & Petroleum NameAddressPhone Name/Address/Phone CITGO outlet - Newcomerstown 565 S River St (740) 498-8905 CITGO outlet - Newcomerstown 300 E Canal St (740) 498-6770 People Also Viewed