List of Casey's Stores in Sheridan, IN Outlet Note Regular Brands Casey's Indiana Sheridan Rating 4.8 based on 84 votes Products Restaurants Fast Food Convenience Stores Pizza Sandwiches Gas Stations Grocery Stores NameAddressPhone Name/Address/Phone Casey's outlet - Sheridan 21737 Mulebarn Rd (317) 694-7521 Casey's outlet - Sheridan 501 S Main St (317) 758-0951 People Also Viewed