List of Jimmy John's Stores in Carmel, IN Outlet Note Regular Brands Jimmy John's Indiana Carmel Rating 4.8 based on 70 votes Official Website https://www.jimmyjohns.com/ NameAddressPhone Name/Address/Phone Jimmy John's Gourmet Sandwiches outlet - Carmel Clay Terrace (317) 571-1800 Jimmy John's outlet - Carmel 2801 E 116th St (317) 566-1180 Jimmy John's outlet - Carmel 9893 N Michigan Rd (317) 334-1800 Jimmy John's outlet - Carmel 365 W 116th St (317) 816-9488 People Also Viewed